The Car Dealership Playbook for Legal Intake

Listen to the full breakdown here →

   

When someone hesitates on an intake call, most law firms treat it like the end of the conversation.

But here’s the truth: it’s not over—it’s just stuck.

This is the moment that separates firms that close from firms that chase. If your team doesn’t have a playbook for what to do when a client says “I need to think about it,” they’re going to lose that lead.

And one of the most powerful tools your intake team can use? Escalation.

The Intake Move Law Firms Are Missing

Let’s say a potential client is 90% there. They’ve shared their story, asked questions, and stayed on the line for 20 minutes.

But then comes the hesitation:
“I just want to talk it over with my spouse…”
“I’m not sure I’m ready to move forward…”

At this moment, most intake specialists say something like:
“No problem—call us back when you’re ready.”

That’s not support. That’s surrender.

Compare that to a car dealership. When a customer says they want to walk away and think about it, the salesperson doesn’t just say goodbye. They bring in the manager.

Not to apply pressure—but to shift the dynamic.

Why Escalation Works (and What It Is)

Escalation isn’t about being aggressive or pushy. It’s about giving the client another voice, another level of credibility, and another reason to say yes.

Here’s what it communicates:

🔵 You matter enough for us to stay with you.
🔵 You’re not just a number—our team is here to help.
🔵 We’re serious about helping you, and we have more resources to support you right now.

It gives the intake team an empowered next step instead of a dead end. And it helps the potential client feel like they’re in good hands.

When to Escalate the Call

Your team needs to know exactly when and how to escalate.

Here are a few clear signals:

• The client is asking the same question multiple times but still seems uncertain.
• They’re stalling with vague phrases like “I just need some time to think.”
• You feel the energy drop—and the sense that the lead is slipping.

That’s the moment to say something like:
“I totally understand. Would it be okay if I brought one of our senior team members on the line? They might be able to give you more clarity on the next steps.”

That’s not pressure—it’s proactive support.

What Escalation Sounds Like in Practice

Let’s break down the framework your team can use:

Step 1: Validate the concern.
“I totally understand wanting to think this over.”

Step 2: Offer a handoff.
“Before we end the call, would it be helpful if I looped in one of our attorneys/partners to answer any lingering questions?”

Step 3: Let leadership lead.
Once escalated, the new person should be briefed and ready to reinforce confidence, not restart the conversation.

This isn’t about “saving the deal.” It’s about supporting the client through uncertainty.

You’re Leaving Money on the Table Without It

Most law firms don’t have a second intake layer. If a lead doesn’t sign on the spot, the call ends, and everyone hopes for a callback.

But here’s the thing: they rarely call back.

To grow your firm, support your intake team with an escalation process.

🔹 Train them to recognize hesitation.
🔹 Teach them how to transition the call with confidence.
🔹 Empower your senior team to handle these moments with care, not pressure.

This small shift creates big wins.

Final Takeaway: The Close Lives in the Follow-Up

When someone hesitates, don’t retreat—escalate.

That moment isn’t the end of the conversation. It’s the start of a new one—with someone even more equipped to handle it.

Great intake is layered. It’s confident. And it’s built for momentum.

If your firm doesn’t have a strategy for escalation, this episode is your blueprint.

🎧 Watch the full episode above.